On Deadly Ground

By Louis Jebb, for Gardening Special, 3 April
2005

Julian and Isabel Bannerman. Portrait by Johny
Shand Kydd (cropped for use on this site)
Later this month, work will begin on turning a
small corner of Manhattan into a garden that will be for ever
Britain. The paving stones in Hanover Square, a few blocks from
Ground Zero, will be lifted to begin digging for The British
Memorial Garden - a place to commemorate the 67 British citizens
killed on September 11.
While few would argue about the merits of the project, some might
raise an eyebrow at the husband-and-wife design team who have been
chosen to undertake such a sober enterprise. For Julian and Isabel
Bannerman are better known as purveyors of extravagantly romantic
English country-house gardens - replete with grottoes, temples and
lush planting schemes. Their idiosyncratic visions have won them a
client list of high-minded grandees which includes the Rothschild,
Getty, Sainsbury, and Pearson families, Lord Lloyd-Webber and even
the Prince of Wales. But it wasn't swanky connections which led to
the memorial garden commission; the Bannermans won a competition two
years ago which pitted them against the cream of Britain's garden
design talent. The challenge, says Julian, was in creating a garden
which not only served its commemorative purpose but which was also
robust enough to survive the harsh New York winters, the quantities
of de-icing salt spread during snowstorms, and the long shadow cast
over Hanover Square by a neighbouring skyscraper. If they'd based
their design on the beau ideal of a herbaceous border, he explains:
"the garden would have been over in a moment".
Their solution was a design based around stone - frostproof stone
from Caithness, Morayshire, Wales and Portland, inscribed with the
names of the counties of Britain - and evergreen topiary shaped
from yew and box.
Stone appealed to the Bannermans for historical reasons (many of
Manhattan's flagstones were imported from Caithness in the 19th
century) and as a medium for carved lettering.

Off the old block: Simon Verity carves
Morayshire stone for the garden.
While working on the project, he went to live in a hut in Caithness
Besides, as Julian points out: "People like
looking at things written in the ground. Americans have a great
tradition of marking their footprints in the ground." The idea for
the inscriptions, he says, came from "the poetry" of the Radio 4
shipping forecast. But instead of weather areas, they chose counties
- as well as London boroughs and British dependencies -
"because you find names like Cambridge, Boston, Somerset all over
the States, so Americans would understand it."
The list of counties will run like a ribbon around the perimeter of
the wedge-shaped garden, enclosing the topiary, raised beds of
cyclamen and mock orange, and serpentine benches made in Portland
stone.
The yew topiary, meanwhile, brings with it a double symbolism - of
remembrance for a long-lived tree associated with British
churchyards and also an added sense of the ancient. "Topiary,"
says Julian, "is timeless."
The project is the latest in a line of work which goes back to
shortly after the Bannermans first met in Edinburgh, in the early
1980s. Isabel Eustace, a softly spoken Pre-Raphaelite beauty, was an
undergraduate at the university, reading history and art history;
Julian Bannerman, ebullient, fluent and trained in the arts ancient
and modern, had already ventured into garden design and was running
Bannermans, a bar and restaurant in the heart of the city's Old
Town. They were married in 1983 and perfected their art by making a
garden of their own at the Ivy, in Chippenham. Until the Bannermans
took it on, the Ivy had seemed a hopeless case. It was a ravishing
Grade I Baroque house in poor condition, its remaining plot of land
hemmed in on two sides by Chippenham's ring road. For years an
owner could not be found. But where others feared to walk, the
Bannermans bravely moved in and - largely with their own hands -
brought a Sleeping Beauty house back to waking life and created a
garden which - with its ranks of pleached limes and rich
herbaceous borders - caught the Zeitgeist of softened, slightly
lush, formality in 1980s country-house gardens.
It was while restoring the Ivy that they received their first
high-profile commission - when the stonemason Simon Verity asked
them to join him in creating a grotto and hermitage at Leeds Castle,
in Kent. Their breakthrough years were the early 1990s when they
worked simultaneously at Waddesdon Manor, in Buckinghamshire - for
Lord Rothschild and the National Trust - restoring the dairy and a
three-acre rock and water garden (unearthing caves, waterfalls and
three lakes), and at Wormsley in the same county for the late John
Paul Getty - creating a grotto-like tunnel between chalk cliffs,
100ft long and 40ft high. Whether they are making gardens formal or
romantic, the Bannermans - who won a Gold Medal at the Chelsea
Flower Show in 1994 - are gardeners of ideas, in tune with the
spirit of where their work. At Highgrove they have made two gardens
for the Prince of Wales, with ferneries, temple groves and a green
oak monument. The Prince gave the Bannermans his Royal warrant in
2002 and has come on board as patron of the garden in New York.
Simon Verity has been one of the Bannermans' main supports in
developing their New York garden design. (Last Friday, a plan of the
garden, carved by Verity, was due to be laid in Grosvenor Square,
London). The other has been Camilla Hellman. A dynamic British
businesswoman living in New York, she conceived the idea of the
garden, found its site, set up and ran the competition to find a
garden designer, and a second for a piece of sculpture for the
garden, won by the celebrated artist Anish Kapoor - and is well on
the way to raising the $6.5m (£3.5m) needed to build it and provide
an endowment for maintenance.
For Hellman, the Bannermans' design has all the quality she hoped
for in the garden, which she proposes will be opened in the summer
of 2006. People who wish to support her fundraising can still
"buy" a county or more from the list of British place names. The
Bannermans, who, for all the poetry in their work, are the most
hands-on of designers, can barely wait for the ground to be broken
and to have what they call their first "dirt session" in the
British Memorial Garden.
Visit www.bannermandesign.com
or www.britishmemorialgarden.org
for more information.
Back
to main news page
|